MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV
Find out the ideal electric car for your needs by comparing two models based on factors such as price, driving range, battery capacity, charging time, colors, and additional features. The ex-showroom price for the MG Comet EV is Rs. 6.99 Lakh, while the Tata Punch EV is priced at Rs. 10.99 Lakh (ex-showroom). In terms of range, the Tata Punch EV offers a range of up to 315 km/charge.
Read more 
Specifications Overview
| Variant Name | Executive | Smart 3.3 |
| On Road Price | Rs.7.36 LakhOn Road Price | Rs.11.63 LakhOn Road Price |
| Body Type | hatchback | SUV |
| Boot Space (Litres) | 350 Litres | 366 Litres |
Body & Suspension
| Colors | APPLE GREEN & STARRY BLACK AURORA SILVER CANDY WHITE & STARRY BLACK CANDY WHITE STARRY BLACK | Daytona Grey Dual Tone Empowered Oxide Dual Tone Fearless Red Dual Tone Pristine White Dual Tone Seaweed Dual Tone |
| Images |    |    |
| Body Type | hatchback | SUV |
| Suspension - Front | Disc | Independent& Lower Wishbone& McPherson Strut with Coil Spring |
| Suspension - Rear | - | Semi-independent Twist Beam with Coil Spring and Shock Absorber |
| Sun Roof | - | No |
| No. of Doors | 3 | - |
| Turning Radius | 4.2 meters | 5 meters |
Engine & Transmission
| Engine Type | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor | Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor |
| No. of Cylinders | Front Only | - |
| Torque | - | 114 Nm |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Electric |
| Cylinder Configuration | Electric Type | - |
| Type | - | Automatic |
| Drivetrain | RWD | - |
| Compression Ratio | Yes | - |
| Fuelling | Electric | - |
| Emission Norm | Not Applicable | Zero Tailpipe Emission |
Comfort & Convenience
| Adjustable Headrests | Front & Rear | - |
| Adjustable steering | Yes | Yes |
| Glove Box Cooling | No | Yes |
| Cruise Control | No | Yes |
| Distance to Empty display | Yes | - |
| Instrument Console | Digital | Digital |
| Keyless Entry | Yes | Yes |
| Multifunction Display | Yes | Yes |
| Multifunction Steering Wheel | Yes | Yes |
| Navigation System | Yes | No |
| Paddle Shifters | - | No |
| Power Steering | - | Yes |
| Power Windows | - | Yes |
| Rain Sensing Wipers | - | No |
| Rear Amrest | - | No |
| Driver's seat height adjustable | - | Yes |
| Speedometer | - | Digital |
| Start / Stop Button | - | Yes |
| Drive Modes | 3 | 2 |
| Fuel level guage | Digital | - |
| Climate Control | - | Yes |
| Reverse Camera | - | No |
Safety
| ABS (Anti-lock Braking System) | Yes | Yes |
| ASR / Traction Control | No | - |
| Auto-Dimming Rear-View Mirror | Manual - Internal Only | - |
| Automatic Headlamps | No | - |
| Central Locking | Keyless | Yes |
| EBA (Electronic Brake Assist) | No | - |
| EBD (Electronic Brake-force Distribution) | Yes | Yes |
| ESP (Electronic Stability Program) | Yes | Yes |
| Hill Assist | Yes | No |
| ISOFIX (Child-Seat Mount) | Yes | Yes |
| Lane Watch Camera/ Side Mirror Camera | No | No |
| Number of Airbags | - | 6 |
Performance & Drivetrain
| Range/Charge | - | 315 km/charge |
Dimensions & Capacity
| Length | 2974 mm | 3857 mm |
| Width | 1505 mm | 1742 mm |
| Height | 1640 mm | 1633 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2010 mm | 2445 mm |
| Ground Clearance | 165 mm | 190 mm |
| Boot Space | 350 Litres | 366 Litres |
Wheels, Tyre & Brakes
| Brakes - Front | LED | Disc |
| Brakes - Rear | - | Drum |
| Front Tyre Size | McPherson Strut | 185/70 R15 |
| Rear Tyre Size | - | 185/70 R15 |
| Wheels Size | R12 | R15 |
Electricals
| Battery Capacity | 17.3 kwh | 25 kwh |
| Motor Power | 17.3 kWh | 60 kW |
Entertainment & Communication
| Android Auto | Yes | No |
| Apple CarPlay | Yes | No |
| Infotainment Screen | No | Yes |
| Voice Recognition | - | No |
Charging
| Charging Time | 7 Hrs | 9.4 Hours |
| Fast Charging | No | - |
Others
| Basic Warranty | 3 Years or 100000 KMS | 3 Year or 125000 km |
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Most affordable EV in India Easily to maneuver in heavy city traffic due to its small dimensions Comes with light steering Includes various advanced features like a rear parking camera, keyless entry, and foldable rear seats The MG Comet EV comes with LED lighting Includes wireless connectivity for Apple Carplay and Android Auto | Delivers an impressive range of up to 412 km per charge (top spec variant). Offers versatile transmission options catering varied driving preferences. Multiple safety features including airbags and ABS. Automatic climate control and adjustable seats boosts convenience with each ride. Practical interior layout with ample space for passengers and cargo. Affordable pricing when considering an electric SUV. Eco-friendly driving where it cuts down on carbon emissions. |
| Cons | Limited interior space due to its compact form factor Not suitable as a primary car Not ideal for long journeys or highways due to lower riding range Four-seater can be a constraint for large families Slow charging speeds where it takes up to 7 hours for a full battery charge Cabin access can be challenging due to two-door design Comes void of rear wipers | Limited range option with the base variant when compared to rival electric SUVs Availability of limited charging infrastructure needs to be addressed Interior materials and finishes may not feel as premium as higher-priced rivals in the market. |
Comet EV Similar Cars Comparisons
- Comet EV vs Tiago EV
MGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *TataTiago EV₹ 7.99 - 11.89 Lakh * - Comet EV vs EaS-EMGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *PMVEaS-E₹ 4.79 Lakh *
- Comet EV vs eC3MGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *CitroeneC3₹ 11.61 - 12.64 Lakh *
- Comet EV vs Xpres-T EVMGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *TataXpres-T EV₹ 13.04 Lakh *
- Comet EV vs R3MGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *Strom MotorsR3₹ 4.50 Lakh *
- Comet EV vs Tigor EVMGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *TataTigor EV₹ 12.49 - 13.75 Lakh *
- Comet EV vs Nexon EVMGComet EV₹ 6.99 - 10.63 Lakh *TataNexon EV₹ 14.49 - 19.49 Lakh *
Punch EV Similar Cars Comparisons
- Punch EV vs Xpres-T EVTataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *TataXpres-T EV₹ 13.04 Lakh *
- Punch EV vs eC3TataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *CitroeneC3₹ 11.61 - 12.64 Lakh *
- Punch EV vs Nexon EVTataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *TataNexon EV₹ 14.49 - 19.49 Lakh *
- Punch EV vs Tigor EVTataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *TataTigor EV₹ 12.49 - 13.75 Lakh *
- Punch EV vs XUV 400 ElectricTataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *MahindraXUV 400 Electric₹ 15.99 - 19.39 Lakh *
- Punch EV vs Tiago EVTataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *TataTiago EV₹ 7.99 - 11.89 Lakh *
- Punch EV vs Curvv EVTataPunch EV₹ 10.99 - 15.49 Lakh *TataCurvv EV₹ 17.49 - 21.99 Lakh *
- Home
- / EV
- / Compare Cars
- / MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV